The Urban Legend

Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

Interior+of+a+thrift+store+on+Haight+street.+By+Ellie+Lerner%2C+staff+writer.
Back to Article
Back to Article

Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

Interior of a thrift store on Haight street. By Ellie Lerner, staff writer.

Interior of a thrift store on Haight street. By Ellie Lerner, staff writer.

Ellie Lerner

Interior of a thrift store on Haight street. By Ellie Lerner, staff writer.

Ellie Lerner

Ellie Lerner

Interior of a thrift store on Haight street. By Ellie Lerner, staff writer.

Ellie Lerner, Staff Writer

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






This December, the Urban school Green Team hosted a school clothing swap in which Urban students donated clothes and were able to choose items to add to their wardrobe from one another’s donations. “The goal,” said Elsie Lipson ‘20, the leader of the clothing swap on Green Team, “[was] to bring awareness to the impact of our buying habits.”

Shopping for clothing has become more harmful with each new fashion micro-season. In a Huffington Post article, Kara Hackett reported that Americans are “buying 400 percent more clothes than we bought just 20 years ago.” Based on the calculations of the World Resources Institute, the average American consumer is purchasing 60 percent more articles of clothing each year while using each garment only half as long.

The increase in the consumption of clothing garments has followed the escalation of fabric production. According to the 2016 “Sustainability & Resource Productivity” report released by the McKinsey & Company, “The number of garments produced annually has doubled since 2000 and exceeded 100 billion for the first time in 2014: nearly 14 items of clothing for every person on earth.”

Driven by the cheap prices of mass-produced fashion and short-lived fashion fads, people are not only buying but also throwing away more clothes than ever before. According to the Ellen MacArthur Foundation, one garbage truck of textiles is wasted every second. In San Francisco alone, the San Francisco Department of the Environment reports that 4,500 pounds of textiles are sent to the landfill every hour by city residents.

The impact of the fast fashion cycle does not end with the inordinate amount of waste generated by overconsumption; much of the environmental impact of our clothes takes place on the production level. An article in Independent Magazine explained that with growing clothing demand, “textile dyeing [has become] the second largest polluter of clean water globally.” In addition to textile dying, the production of non-organic cotton uses strong pesticides that contribute to chemical pollution in water and soil while polyesters produce small, plastic microfibers that end up in waterways and the ocean food chain.  

The overconsumption and over-production of clothes in recent years has sparked environmental concern, leading some consumers to become more aware of the impact of their buying habits. Bell Davis ‘19 said that she finds “fast fashion really disturbing, both from a humanitarian perspective and an environmental perspective, and I think that it’s a larger reflection of how so many people look at our time on earth on a day by day basis and don’t really think about the long term impact of their choices.”

The clothing swap at Urban also coincided with a push in San Francisco to address the environmental impact of textile waste. In 2014, San Francisco was the first city to implement a textile recycling program. By placing textiles on top of recycling bins, residents are able to recycle their used or unwanted clothing items.

While the recycling of discarded textiles into new materials has become increasingly popular as a solution to textile waste, many environmental organizations have opposed this model. Greenpeace, a global environmental non-profit, explained that “behind this nice phrase lies the industry’s fantasy that circularity can fix a material-intensive system.” Unfortunately, the technology for recycling fabrics is not developed to the point that old clothes can be 100% recycled into new fabric and even with partial recyclability, the process releases carbon dioxide into the air and contributes to global warming. A report released by Greenpeace warned that the circular fashion model also protects the profits of the fast fashion industry since “the overconsumption of textiles is the larger problem that must be tackled. In addition, the promotion of the circularity myth that clothes could be ‘infinitely recycled’ may even be increasing guilt-free consumption.”  

Alternatively, thrift shops, resale stores, and clothing swaps help combat both the overproduction and overconsumption of clothing. As articulated by Eloise Brotzman ‘21, San Franciscans are beginning to realize that “there are really three options when you want to buy to new clothes. One is that you go to a big brand like H and M or Forever Twentyone where it’s cheap and mass produced but also really bad for the environment. The second option is to go to a boutique clothing shop that is not as bad for the environment but also really expensive. The third option is thrifting which is a blend of the two other options since its both environmentally friendly and cheap; thrift stores really are the perfect solution.”

This past year, San Francisco Lowell High School also hosted a clothing swap in which 500 articles of clothing were donated and swapped by students. Kristen Tam, a senior at Lowell who organized the clothing swap, said that the school’s environmental club was “inspired by the increasing number of students thrifting nowadays and we wanted to share that with everyone in the school community. I think it helped break the stigma around wearing used clothes because it was in a school environment and so people felt more comfortable wearing clothes from people that they actually knew.”

Tara Kamali ‘19, who says she thrifts almost every weekend, explained that thrifting has become a popular trend among Urban students: “There will be times when I’ll see something at a thrift store then come into school the next day and see someone else wearing it. I think that since Urban has a lot more affluent families, the appeal of thrifting is not so much the cheap prices but more that vintage is trendy.”

Urban’s Green Team successfully capitalized on this popular trend, hosting a clothing swap in which students traded 100 items of clothing. Lipson explained that “because the clothing swap went so well, [Green Team is] going to try to do one every term.” By using purchasing power to descale clothing production levels, Lipson concludes that “we can put pressure on these [clothing] companies to think a little bit more sustainably.”

By Kian Nassre, Web Editor
Infographic of various statistics related to textile production and waste.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Navigate Left
  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Features

    Humans of Flik Dining

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Arts and Culture

    New Netflix originals reach an all-time high in viewership

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Features

    2018: A year of developments for the #MeToo movement

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Arts and Culture

    The amazing pets of Urban

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Features

    Inside teacher offices

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Features

    Passage of Prop C may not be enough to solve SF homelessness crisis

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    News

    Midterm Madness V: What’s Next?

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    News

    Midterm Madness Part IV: What Happened

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    News

    The deadliest act of anti-Semitism in American history

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    News

    San Francisco votes to tax the rich to benefit the poor with Prop C

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Online Exclusive

    Girls varsity season ends with 3-7 loss to Sacred Heart

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Arts and Culture

    Behind Urban’s unique stonecarving class

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    News

    Midterm Madness Part III: What to Watch

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Arts and Culture

    A Halloween to Remember

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    News

    Midterm Madness Part II: What to Know

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    News

    Midterm Madness Part I: What’s Going On

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Features

    People of the White Privilege Conference

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Arts and Culture

    Teachers share their first kiss stories

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Arts and Culture

    Posters, traditional Chinese dancing, and a political prisoner: investigating Shen Yun’s religious connections

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Features

    Unlocking Locker Culture at Urban

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Features

    From Auto Showrooms to Movie Theaters: The History of Van Ness Avenue

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    News

    Agreement reached after Oakland teacher strike, but is it enough?

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Arts and Culture

    The note-taking hall of fame

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Features

    Male athletes at Urban discuss sexual harassment

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Features

    Argentine ants at Urban

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    News

    New papal edict attempts to address long history of sexual abuse in the Catholic Church

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Opinions

    Opinion: Your ‘museum’ selfie is not art

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Opinions

    Opinion: Zion Williamson and the case for paying college athletes

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Features

    Reproductive rights endangered at the Mexico-United States border

  • Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution

    Arts and Culture

    There’s something about true crime

Navigate Right
The School Newspaper of The Urban School of San Francisco
Green is the new black: thrifting could be the answer to fast fashion pollution