Organic food may not be worth it, new Stanford Medical study finds

Back to Article
Back to Article

Organic food may not be worth it, new Stanford Medical study finds

Aideen Murphy

Tessa Petrich (far right) sets up a taste test for Legend staffers on Oct. 4

Tessa Petrich, Staff Writer

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






Urban Legend Staff participates in a taste test between various organic and conventional fruits

How often do you pay the extra dollar per pound for those crisp organic apples? As it turns out, according to a Stanford Medical study released Sept. 4, organic produce isn’t healthier than the conventional kind.

Does that mean that food shopping has become more like clothing shopping? Is the term “organic” a designer label to get us to pay more?

A rigorous, four-decade-long Stanford Medical study led by Dean Bravata, senior affiliate with Stanford’s Center for Health Policy, and Crystal Smith-Spangler, a Stanford instructor in the Division of General Medical Disciplines and a physician-investigator at VA Palo Alto Health Care System, showed that organic foods are not more nutritious than conventional foods. The study compared nutrient levels along with the bacterial, fungal or pesticide contamination in produce, grains, and animal products.

The analysis found “little significant difference in health benefits between organic and conventional foods” and “no consistent differences” when it came to vitamins, apart from the bone-building nutrient phosphorus, which “was significantly higher in organic versus conventionally grown produce.” Researchers also found no protein or fat difference between organic and non-organic milk.

Urban students are split on whether organic food lives up to its expectations.

“Organic is a good idea in theory, and is a good starting point for sustainable eating,” said Sophie Drukman-Feldstein (’16). “My family tries to eat organic (and) we generally prioritize local food over organic food, because the transportation of food over long distances is terrible for the environment.”

But Sam Denton (’16) disagreed: “I think organic food is a waste of money — it tastes the same.”

“Organic (produce) is more ecologically sustainable,” said Geoff Ruth, Urban science teacher, junior and senior dean, and former head of Urban’s Green Team.

“It’s also better for farmer workers because they aren’t exposed to pesticides and herbicides, so there’s sort of this social justice aspect of it.”

Even so, “clearly it’s better to buy locally grown oranges that have pesticides on them then buying oranges from Chile at some time when oranges aren’t available here that are organic,” said Ruth.

In a Legend blind taste test, staffers picked conventionally grown apples over the organic kind, but organic strawberries over conventional strawberries. The choice of blueberries — organic or not — was a draw.

While the nutritional value and even the flavor of organic food may not be different from its conventional counterparts, there are other reasons to dish out the extra cash. Community Supported Agriculture (CSA)  boxes help small farms stay in business: A typical box is about $25 and has enough fruits and vegetables to feed two to four people for a week. On the other hand, families could buy the same amount of conventional fruits and vegetables for about half the price at Safeway.

The best solution? “Grow your own food if you can,” advised Ruth. His garden at home is “pretty huge … we haven’t bought fruit in, like, three weeks.” But if growing your own food isn’t an option, Geoff recommends to “go to some of the farmer’s markets that are cheaper.”

“I believe that organic food is worth the extra money if you have the extra money,” said Drukman-Feldstein. “The fact is, in this society, healthy and ethical food is a privilege this needs to change.”

Check out EWG’s 2012 Shopper’s Guide to Pesticides in Produce for help when choosing between organic and conventional produce. The clean 15 and the dirty dozen are great resources for deciding what to buy and what not to buy when you’re at the grocery store.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email